Diablo IV: A Measured Return to Darkness and Addictive Depth

A Darker, Morbid Tone Reclaimed

Diablo IV marks a striking return to the franchise’s roots, plunging players back to a bleak, oppressive world teeming with morbidity and despair. Where Diablo III and Immortal had a glowing and cartoonish world, Diablo IV reclaimed the sombre, gothic ambience of the original Diablo and Diablo II.

A spectral trickster conjures illusions that confound and deceive, leaving enemies unsure of what is real and what is mere deception.

This tonal decision is not skin-deep; it plays a significant role in shaping player immersion. A sense of hopelessness and stagnation permeates the world, designed in a way that gives weight to every choice and every interaction, in every battle, and every stray encounter. The score, artwork, and sounds combine to capture a sense of dread and isolation, a feeling that was at times softened in prior installments by more dialogue, humor, and relief. The Diablo IV experience, while certainly melancholic, is not monotonous. The emotional depth of the story in the game is a welcome addition and rare for the series, of which much has been more focused on action and superficial elements.

Gameplay Loop and Pacing Logic in Diablo IV

Most importantly, Diablo IV exploits a finely tuned gameplay loop consisting of various elements wherein the intervals on the feedback loop in question can be described as delivering a “faultless rhythm” within the constraints of a very finely tuned engagement-indicative temporal structure. Within a session, the game continuously re-establishes points of engagement over a sustained period of time, and within one such session, the game functions by successively activating various points of engagement. Fundamentally, at the core of this structure is a well-timed cadence on the distribution of incremental rewards on the game loop, calibrated just enough to balance the flow and maintain sustained intervals of engagement. These rewards can be new levels, loot, access to new areas, and access to missions of varying difficulty.

A rift stalker disappears into the fabric of reality, slipping between dimensions and launching surprise attacks from unexpected angles.

This cadence and flow of rewards is reminiscent of the golden era of MMORPGs in the mid-2000s, with games like World of Warcraft, where even the most trivial and meaningless rewards were systematically designed to encourage players to engage. Diablo IV builds on this principle, now adopting a hybrid model as the core gameplay is an Action RPG. Diablo IV is also one of the very few games in the market to have such a calibrated system of engagement on either side of the gameplay. Most games designed to stimulate and engage players usually either have very fast and overwhelming action systems or very slow and frustrating systems to progress. In Diablo IV, rewards in the form of levels and rare items in the game are sufficiently frequent to be gratifying, and spaced enough to maintain a sense of achievement.

A celestial vindicator channels celestial wrath, summoning divine energy to smite evildoers and protect the innocent.

Even in familiar places, the possibility of unseen loot or the next quest line beckons players to delve deeper. While players can tend to the main story arc, side missions, and dynamic world events also occur in the players’ orbit, giving them the choice to satisfy the more freeform or more structured approach to exploration.

Absence of a Follower System: Isolation and Emphasis on Multiplayer

The removal of the AI followers in Diablo III has had the biggest mechanical impact. In Diablo III, followers provided companionship, integrated narrative, and tactical advantages within battles and softened the loneliness of stretches in the journey. Diablo IV omitting this feature is a bold decision, but thematically, it makes sense. For players who choose to play alone, the increased sense of vulnerability adds to the tension and immersion because there is no AI companion, and every encounter is deeply felt. The player is forced to rely completely on their own skills and equipment, amplifying the sense of solitary heroism and isolation. 

A rune-scribed warrior harnesses the power of ancient symbols etched into their armor, enhancing their combat prowess with each strike.

Diablo IV is still socially dynamic, however. In this sense, the lack of AI followers is a conscious decision. The solitary experience may be more oppressive and bleak, but the cooperative experience is more rewarding and enriching. The design choice that serves the darker aspect of the game so well is the lack of permanent AI followers. Diablo III had AI companions, Kormac the Templar, and every so often, he would shout encouragements. Diablo IV lacks these, and so, every so often, the silence and lack of encouragement become thunderous. As a solo player who buys cheap PS4 games, in Diablo IV, bleakness truly is all you have. You have the isolation of cursed cathedrals and blighted fields, the silence is profound, and the only companions are the restless wind and the undead. This bleakness is the only thing that makes your every win feel haunting and your every loss feel personal.

Although this shift toward solitary dread exists, there are still other players in the game. There is no AI companion, but other players cross the same fields, gather in towns, and join you in multiplayer activities. There is an interesting duality, as the narrative and tone focus on isolation, and systemic design promotes community. For some players, the impressive spell effects cast by other players can pose a possible immersion loss.

Character and Loot Progression: My Journey as a Player

In its most fundamental form, Diablo IV is an isometric action RPG and revolves around one core loop, as most other action RPGs do, of character progression by gaining loot to customize skills. There are five classes, each with its own mechanics and unique strategic potentials, and which one can pick: Rogues, Sorcerers, Barbarians, Druids, and Necromancers. There is therefore scope for diverse gameplay, from the soul-crushing sorcery of the sorcerer to the shapeshifting brute Druid whose sheer force can dominate.

A spectral chronomancer manipulates time itself, rewinding the clock to reverse injuries or speeding up time to outmaneuver their foes.

The loot that is dropped makes different character builds possible and gives players the ability to make strategic character choices, and loot is not just thrown at players to “power-up” characters. Players can experiment with stats, skill trees, and gear, and can create builds that are much more complex while staying within the given class. This system is designed in a way that can attract not only the veterans and players who enjoy the complex systems of character building, but also the new players who enjoy the simple and straightforward character progression system.

A soulbinder taps into the life force of their foes, draining their vitality to replenish their own and fuel their devastating spells.

Moreover, the progression pacing in Diablo IV is more realistic and ‘down to earth’ in a sense. The system does not rely on random spikes of power and does not go to either extreme, staying too fast or too slow. This is an addictive system as players continue to run through the world in an attempt to gain that next incremental power-up, better weapon, or a newly augmented skill to the point where players realize they are ‘grinding’ for that next boss fight.

Addictive Quality and Player Experience: A Balanced Warning

To help convey the steep addictiveness of Diablo IV, I start with a personal story. Like the mid-2000s World of Warcraft stories, Diablo IV players can become so immersed in the game that they forget to take breaks. Players feel a sense of achievement due to the small, manageable goals and the lure of large, powerful, tougher enemies.

A storm sentinel conjures mighty tempests, wielding thunder and lightning to unleash destructive storms upon their enemies.

While, to Diablo IV, the engaging nature of immersion is a blessing, the opposite holds true in the rest of the world. The social and physical ramifications of immersion can be profound, and the need to chase 'one more' mission can become toxic.

Though Diablo IV can be at times designed to feel manipulative and coercive, it invites intentional play. There is an intent to reward mastery while still allowing for breaks.

Comments